After the Midterm Elections, Nonprofits Should Double Down on Their People
Author
Article Summary
The midterm election results may change the outlook for federal funding, but nonprofits don't need to wait for clarity in Washington to support their staff. This article explains how nonprofit leaders can strengthen their workforce on a tight budget by rethinking workloads, protecting the benefits employees value most, and bringing staffing needs into board and funder conversations.
For nonprofit leaders, midterm election results create an opening to reconsider what comes next. Shifts in Congress bring renewed attention to federal funding and the sector's relationship with government. Divided government also leaves room for budget negotiations, continued executive action, and uncertainty about when policy changes will reach communities.
It would be premature to treat the results as a guarantee of stability. It would also be a mistake to spend this window waiting. Nonprofits should use this moment to strengthen the workforce they’ll need under any political scenario.
That’s a tougher conversation when revenue is uncertain. Leaders need to preserve cash and sustain services. But postponing every staff-related expense carries costs: vacancies that burden remaining employees, managers who lack support, and experienced people who leave with relationships and knowledge that cannot be quickly replaced. As the Urban Institute reported in 2025, 72% of staffed nonprofits reported that employee vacancies hurt their ability to pursue their missions.
Three Practical Ways to Double Down
Start with the work itself. Ask employees where capacity is breaking down. Revisit priorities and eliminate low-value tasks. Consider where AI, paired with training and human oversight, could reduce administrative work and give staff more time for relationships, judgment, and service. That people-first approach is central to Workforce Intelligence, the book by OneDigital’s Mike Sullivan and Vinay Gidwaney, which treats AI transformation as a people decision. The opportunity is to reinvest that capacity in employees and mission delivery.
Protect what employees actually value. Review compensation competitiveness, benefits affordability, and retirement readiness together. A modest change in one area can matter more to employees than a larger change in another, and looking at all three helps you see where your budget makes the biggest difference. Ask staff what matters most to them before making changes. OneDigital’s total rewards, employee benefits, and retirement specialists help nonprofits weigh those choices against financial realities. Where resources are limited, explain decisions honestly. Staff can understand constraints; silence leaves them to draw their own conclusions.
Bring workforce capacity into the boardroom. Funding scenarios often focus on programs and revenue. They should also show the staff needed to deliver each version of the plan. For each scenario, map which roles are essential, where current staff are already stretched, and what would need to change if funding shifts. That gives boards a clearer view of tradeoffs before decisions are made. OneDigital’s HR Consulting experts support workforce planning, organizational design, and leadership development to connect ambition with achievable staffing decisions. Boards and funders should ask whether the outcomes they expect are adequately resourced.
The Work That Can Start Now
The connection between staff investment and mission delivery guides OneDigital’s commitment to the sector. Pete Gruenberg, who leads our national industry and program strategy, brings the perspective of a longtime employee benefits advisor.
“Serving on nonprofit boards, I see the difficult choices leaders face when resources are stretched. My years in employee benefits have shown me how much thoughtful workforce investment can matter.”
Doubling down doesn’t mean doubling the budget. It means being deliberate about what helps people stay, contribute, and grow.
Nonprofit leaders don’t need to wait for Washington to make their workforce a priority. Use this time to identify where staff need support, make the choices your resources allow, and bring your board and funders into the conversation. Supporting the people who carry the mission forward is work that can start now.
Planning your next steps? OneDigital's Nonprofit Center of Excellence brings together HR, benefits, retirement, and total rewards expertise to help nonprofits make thoughtful workforce choices, support their people, and sustain their missions under any funding scenario.